Skip to content

milisp/misleading-macos-damaged-warning

Repository files navigation

❌ Misleading macOS “App is Damaged” Warning

macOS users often encounter this misleading message in old versions:

“App is damaged and should be moved to the Trash.”

In reality, the app is usually not damaged at all — it simply lacks Apple notarization or signature.

macOS new versions

Apple could not verify [AppName] is free of malware that may harm your Mac or compromise your privacy.

If this project helped you, please consider giving it a ⭐ on GitHub! GitHub Stars


💥 Why This Warning Is Misleading

  • The word “damaged” implies corruption or malware, but most of the time the app is just unsigned.
  • Users are misled into deleting perfectly safe software.
  • Apple could use a more accurate term like “Unverified” or “Not Signed”.

📉 The Real-World Cost

Conservative estimates show:

  • 🧑‍💻 100,000 developers affected
  • 📉 Over 1 million users abandoned apps due to this warning
  • 🕒 Developers waste ~2 hours each explaining and repackaging
  • 💵 Estimated productivity loss: $15,000,000+

Time Lost Pie Chart


🧪 Real-World Cases

See More than 50 CASES.md for community-submitted stories, or view a few highlights below:

📁 CASE: All Files Marked as Damaged After macOS Monterey Update

Apple Forum

“All my Word, Excel, and PDF files suddenly show 'is damaged' after updating macOS.”

💻 CASE: Third-Party Apps Blocked on macOS Ventura

Reddit

“Gatekeeper disabled, but Ventura still reports app is 'damaged'. Misleading and unhelpful.”


🗣️ Real-World Reports

If you’ve encountered this issue with your users, feel free to open an issue or PR describing:

  • Your app packaging method
  • How users downloaded it
  • What fixed it (if anything)

🛠️ How to Bypass This Warning

If you trust the app, bypass it with:

xattr -rd com.apple.quarantine /path/to/your.app

Or use “Right-click → Open” in Finder.

🎥 Watch: How to Fix “App is damaged and can’t be opened” on macOS (YouTube)


🤝 What We Want

  • 📢 Apple should revise this message to something accurate, like “App is not signed.”
  • 🧑‍💻 Developers deserve clarity and trust
  • 🛡️ Users deserve confidence when using safe apps

📬 Get Involved

  • ✍️ Submit your story → CASES.md
  • 🐛 File an Issue
  • ⭐ Star this repo to show support
  • 🔁 Share with your community

GitHub Stars

About

Apple’s fake “App is Damaged” warning wastes time and destroys trust. This repo calls for change

Resources

License

Stars

Watchers

Forks