Add page for ICBO 2025 workshop, "Accelerating Ontology Curation with Agentic AI and GitHub"

[caufieldjh]

Work in progress.

[claude]

Claude finished @caufieldjh's task —— View job

---

PR Review: ICBO 2025 Workshop Page

Reviewing this pull request for code quality, best practices, and alignment with project guidelines.

Todo List:

• Read and analyze changed files
• Review content against CLAUDE.md guidelines
• Check mkdocs.yml configuration changes
• Provide specific feedback and recommendations

Review Summary

This PR adds a new tutorial page for an ICBO 2025 workshop. Overall, the changes are well-structured and align with the project's goals, but the content is incomplete and needs development to meet the repository's standards.

Code Quality & Best Practices ✅

mkdocs.yml changes (line 48):

• Configuration change is correct and properly formatted
• Navigation entry follows existing patterns
• Title matches the document heading

Content Analysis & Recommendations

Strengths:

• Clear, descriptive title that aligns with the project's focus on AI-assisted ontology curation
• Abstract effectively explains the problem space and workshop goals
• Content addresses the target audience (ontology developers) identified in CLAUDE.md:65-69

Areas for Improvement:

1. Content Completeness ⚠️

   • Currently only contains an abstract (9 lines total)
   • Missing practical, step-by-step content required by project standards (CLAUDE.md:49-50)
   • Needs hands-on exercises and implementation details mentioned in the abstract

2. Structure Alignment 📋

   • Should follow tutorial format established in the repository
   • Consider adding sections like:
     • Prerequisites
     • Learning objectives
     • Step-by-step hands-on exercises
     • Tools and setup instructions
     • Practical examples with real ontologies (Mondo, Uberon, GO mentioned in abstract)

3. Actionability Gap ⚠️

   • Abstract mentions "practical hands-on guide" but no practical content exists yet
   • Violates CLAUDE.md:49 requirement for "practical, immediately actionable content"
   • Should include working examples and concrete implementation steps

Security & Performance 🔒

• No security concerns identified
• Static documentation has minimal performance impact
• No external dependencies or scripts introduced

Test Coverage 🧪

• Documentation changes don't require automated tests
• Manual verification needed:
  • MkDocs builds successfully
  • Navigation links work correctly
  • Content renders properly in Material theme

Recommendations for Completion

Before merging, consider:

1. Add substantive tutorial content following the project's practical focus
2. Include step-by-step exercises that deliver on the "hands-on" promise
3. Provide working examples with actual ontology projects
4. Test the MkDocs build locally with mkdocs serve

The foundation is solid, but this needs significant content development to meet the repository's standards for immediately actionable, practical guidance.