Skip to content

Conversation

@cmungall
Copy link
Member

Add comprehensive reference documentation for the curation-skills repository.

This documentation:

  • Provides a high-level overview of Claude skills functionality
  • Documents the three available skills (OAK, OBO Ontologies, DOSDP)
  • Explains installation methods (plugin marketplace and copy-paste)
  • Includes use cases and target audience
  • Links to the main repository for detailed documentation

Resolves #46

Generated with Claude Code

- Create comprehensive reference page for curation-skills repository
- Add navigation entry in mkdocs.yml
- Include installation methods, available skills, and use cases
- Follows repository guidelines for practical, actionable content

Resolves #46

Co-authored-by: Chris Mungall <[email protected]>
@claude
Copy link
Contributor

claude bot commented Oct 22, 2025

Claude finished @cmungall's task —— View job


Code Review for Claude Skills Documentation

Reviewing the PR that adds Claude Skills documentation. Here's my progress:

Todo List

  • Read and analyze the new documentation file
  • Review mkdocs.yml changes
  • Check compliance with repository documentation standards
  • Verify content accuracy and completeness
  • Provide comprehensive review feedback

Review Feedback

This is a well-structured documentation addition that aligns with the repository's goals. Here's my detailed review:

Strengths

  1. Excellent Content Structure: The documentation follows a logical flow from introduction → overview → specific skills → installation → use cases → getting started.

  2. Appropriate Target Audience: Content clearly targets the repository's primary audience of "curators and maintainers of knowledge bases" as specified in CLAUDE.md.

  3. Practical Focus: Adheres to the repository's mission of providing "practical, immediately actionable content" rather than theoretical discussions.

  4. Good Integration:

    • mkdocs.yml:50 correctly adds the new page to the Reference section
    • Internal links properly reference existing documentation (lines 63, 68-69)
  5. Clear Installation Instructions: Provides both plugin marketplace and copy-paste methods with specific commands.

⚠️ Minor Issues & Suggestions

  1. Link Verification Needed (docs/reference/claude-skills.md:63):

    • The link to ../how-tos/index.md references a file that doesn't exist in the repository
    • Consider linking to the existing how-tos section or removing this reference
  2. Consistency with Repository Standards:

    • The content appropriately focuses on practical implementation over theory ✅
    • Follows existing Material theme styling patterns ✅
    • Maintains consistency with other reference documentation ✅
  3. Content Accuracy:

    • All external links point to legitimate resources
    • Skills descriptions are accurate and informative
    • Installation methods are clearly explained

📋 Code Quality Assessment

  • No Security Concerns: Documentation-only changes with no executable code
  • No Performance Issues: Static documentation with minimal impact
  • No Bug Risks: Well-formatted Markdown with proper syntax
  • Test Coverage: N/A for documentation (but links should be verified)

🔍 Technical Review

  • mkdocs.yml Changes: Single line addition at line 50 is appropriate and follows existing navigation structure
  • Markdown Quality: Proper heading hierarchy, consistent formatting, appropriate use of code blocks
  • File Organization: Correctly placed in docs/reference/ following repository structure

📝 Recommendation

Approve with Minor Fix: This is a high-quality documentation addition that enhances the repository's value. The only issue is the broken internal link which should be addressed before merging.


Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

Add documentation on use of Claude skills

2 participants